| Platinum | Rio Grande Mexican Restaurant |
| Gold | The Taco Stop |
| Silver | Inca Mexican Restaurant |
| Bronze | Taqueria Los Comales |
| Top Pick | 3 Margaritas Fort Collins |
| Top Pick | Cafe Mexicali |
| Top Pick | La Buena Vida |
| Top Pick | Los Tarascos |
| Top Pick | Momma Perez Burritos |
| Top Pick | Pueblo Viejo |