| Platinum | The Bread Chic |
| Gold | The Cache At Ginger & Baker |
| Silver | Nothing Bundt Cakes |
| Bronze | Crumbl Cookies - Fort Collins |
| Top Pick | Babalu's Cuban Cafe |
| Top Pick | Fiona's Delicatessan & Catering |
| Top Pick | Mary's Mountain Cookies |
| Top Pick | Retreat Bakery Bar |