| Platinum | Paradice Cream Loveland |
| Gold | Walrus Ice Cream Co. |
| Silver | Cold Stone Creamery |
| Bronze | Josh & John's |
| Top Pick | Berry Blendz |
| Top Pick | Gelato & aMore |
| Top Pick | Glacier Ice Cream Fort Collins |
| Top Pick | Kilwins Fort Collins |
| Top Pick | Nieves Y Botanas Del Bajio |
| Top Pick | Saffron Scoops N Bites |