| Platinum | BeauJo's Pizza |
| Gold | Panino's Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | Slyce Pizza Co |
| Bronze | Panhandlers Pizza |
| Top Pick | Emporium Sports Bar |
| Top Pick | Mama Roni's Pizza |
| Top Pick | My Empanadas |
| Top Pick | Pizza Casbah |
| Top Pick | Pulcinella Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Surfside 7 |