| Platinum | Mugs Old Town |
| Gold | Rainbow Restaurant |
| Silver | The Human Bean |
| Bronze | Gib's New York Bagels |
| Top Pick | Babalus Cuban Cuisine |
| Top Pick | Bindle Coffee |
| Top Pick | Ft Collins Coffeehouse |
| Top Pick | Harbinger Coffee |
| Top Pick | Lima Coffee Roasters |
| Top Pick | The Crooked Cup |